I ordered 2 sets, 1 had a cracked waste basket, the replacement they sent had a cracked tray, the 3rd set they sent was fine. They are very nice looking and pretty precisely made as far as clean seams and lines. However be prepared for returns, as 2 out of 4 sets I received were damaged. It's just an issue with the bamboo cracking as it dries out. Three of the sets cotton ball or q-tip boxes had fairly tight fitting lids, but that is easily remedied with a little sanding. I'm just glad they make returns so easy, otherwise this would have been very frustrating.